The largest U.S. companies found it much harder to extend payments to suppliers in 2022, and have likely hit a ceiling on the practice of supplier payment terms optimization that has historically helped them bolster their balance sheets, according to new working capital research from The Hackett Group, Inc. (NASDAQ: HCKT).
An analysis of data from 1,000 of the largest U.S. public companies by The Hackett Group® showed that in 2022 days payable outstanding (DPO), or the number of days companies take to pay suppliers, decreased by nearly five days, or 8%.
After a rare Triple-Crown event in 2021, where companies saw improvement in all three working capital management metrics – receivables, payable, and inventory – companies saw their overall working capital performance or cash conversion cycle (CCC) worsen by 3% in 2022, as they faced major headwinds such as inflationary pressure on costs, supply chain disruptions and increased geo-political instability. While receivables (days sales outstanding or DSO) improved by 5% and inventory levels (days inventory outstanding or DIO) improved by 3%, the improvements were eclipsed by the significant degradation in payables (days payables outstanding or DPO).
Contributing factors to the improvement in inventory performance (DIO) were strong demand that depleted inventory levels and lessons learned during the pandemic, which has led best-in-class companies to take a more strategic approach to inventory management and rely on technology to optimize inventory amid sustained and shifting customer demand, the research found.
Receivables (DSO) performance improvement was mainly driven by double-digit improvements in consumer durables, recreational products, airlines, and oil and gas, which saw strong demand as a result of continued economic rebound. DSO in other industries benefited from the expansion of subscription models and business-to-consumer sales channels as those continue to alter the customer/supplier dynamic and positively impact receivables performance.
These U.S. companies now have almost $1.9 trillion tied up in excess working capital, the research found, including $666 billion in excess inventory, $665 billion in payables, and $531 billion in receivables. Top performers now collect from customers 42% (19 days) faster, hold 59% (41 days) less inventory, and take 52% (25 days) longer to pay suppliers.
The Hackett Group’s 2023 Working Capital Survey is currently featured on CFO.com. A summary of the research findings, including detailed industry analysis and working capital improvement recommendations, is available on a complimentary basis, with registration, at this link: https://go.poweredbyhackett.com/23wcscc2306
Overall revenue growth continued to exceed normal levels in 2022, increasing by 15%, slower than last year but still far exceeding the 4% to 5% annual average growth pre-pandemic, the research found. Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) margins saw an unusual 3% decline in 2022, as raw material and labor pressure offset any gains in the last two years through digital transformation and other efforts. Cash on hand as a percentage of revenue also dropped by 19%, nearly returning to pre-pandemic levels, as companies used cash hoarded during the pandemic to improve operational performance and pay off debt.
The research, which looks at performance by company and by industry, found the strongest working capital improvements in several industries: airlines; hotels, restaurants and recreation; oil and gas; and wholesale distributors. Industries where companies saw the greatest degradation of working capital performance included: motor vehicles; semiconductors and equipment; computer hardware and peripherals; and household and personal care.
According to The Hackett Group Director Shawn Townsend, “After the ‘great working capital reset’ of 2021, this is a year of course correction and growth, despite significant challenges in the business environment. As we predicted in mid-2022, it appears that companies have reached an inflection point in their ability to improve their balance sheet by extending payments to suppliers. For a decade or more, this practice has been the easiest way for companies to improve their working capital performance, and companies have heavily relied on it. But now, supply assurance is a bigger challenge than ever for most companies, with many facing issues related to supplier criticality, competition for resources and the availability of supply.
“We expect this trend of worsening payables performance to continue in 2023, especially as the restructuring of several major regional banks will likely lead to less availability of supply chain finance assets,” said Townsend. “In addition, the new accounting disclosure rules introduced by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) requiring companies to disclose information about their supply chain finance programs has softened the demand for such tools.”
The Hackett Group Director István Bodó added “It’s interesting to note that the working capital performance gap between typical companies and top performers continues to widen, driven by the degradation of the median performers rather than the improvement of the top performers as seen in previous years. The ratio of top-to-median performance usually traded at an average of ~2.95 in the last few years has now widened by 10% to reach 3.30.”
“With higher interest rates, persistent inflation, continued market unpredictability and many of the other major challenges companies are facing, companies must focus on optimizing working capital if they are to remain competitive long term,” said Bodó. “Cash flow management should be a top priority on the corporate agenda to provide liquidity for strategic investments.”
About The Hackett Group
The Hackett Group, Inc. (NASDAQ: HCKT) is a leading benchmarking, research advisory and strategic consultancy firm that enables organizations to achieve Digital World Class® performance.
Drawing upon our unparalleled intellectual property from more than 25,000 benchmark studies and our Hackett-Certified® best practices repository from the world’s leading businesses – including 97% of the Dow Jones Industrials, 93% of the Fortune 100, 73% of the DAX 40 and 52% of the FTSE 100 – captured through our leading benchmarking platform Quantum Leap® and our Digital Transformation Platform, we accelerate digital transformations, including enterprise cloud implementations.
The Hackett Group, Hackett-Certified, quadrant logo, World Class Defined and Enabled, Quantum Leap, Digital World Class and Hackett Excelleration Matrix are the registered marks of The Hackett Group.
Cautionary Statement Regarding “Forward-Looking” Statements
This release contains “forward-looking” statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933 as amended and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. Statements including without limitation, words such as “expects,” “anticipates,” “intends,” “plans,” “believes,” seeks,” “estimates,” or other similar phrases or variations of such words or similar expressions indicating, present or future anticipated or expected occurrences or outcomes are intended to identify such forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are not statements of historical fact and involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause the Company’s actual results, performance or achievements to be materially different from the results, performance or achievements expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements. Factors that may impact such forward-looking statements include without limitation, the ability of The Hackett Group to effectively market its digital transformation and other consulting services, competition from other consulting and technology companies that may have or develop in the future, similar offerings, the commercial viability of The Hackett Group and its services as well as other risk detailed in The Hackett Group’s reports filed with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission. The Hackett Group does not undertake any duty to update this release or any forward-looking statements contained herein.
Gary Baker, Global Communications Director - (917) 796-2391 or firstname.lastname@example.org